Ask a Franciscan
When Did Jesus become a Catholic?
Pat McCloskey, OFM
February 12, 2026
Q: A few years ago, I overheard a Catholic woman ask her friend, “When did Jesus become a Catholic?” A few of us laughed but did try to explain that Jesus was the Christ. He was born Jewish and died Jewish.
One of my Jewish friends asked me, “When did Jesus become a Christian?” Soon after that, a relative asked me, “Well, when did he become a Catholic?” Please address these questions in your column.
Admitting Gross Historical Injustices
Pat McCloskey, OFM
February 9, 2026
Call it tribalism, but I’ve always cast a skeptical eye on the Dominicans ever since I learned about their role in the Inquisition. Do you have any advice for thinking about historical misdeeds?
Read More →
Who Informed the Biblical Writers?
Pat McCloskey, OFM
February 4, 2026
How did the gentlemen who gathered together to write the Bible do so? Where did their information come from? The holy Bible is beautifully written. When was it written? How did they know all the details? Ultimately, God inspired them ...
Read More →
Origins of the Celibacy Rule
Pat McCloskey, OFM
January 28, 2026
When did the Roman Catholic Church begin to require celibacy before a man could be ordained a priest? Why? Doesn’t this suggest that marriage is inferior to celibacy?
Read More →
What about Reincarnation?
Pat McCloskey, OFM
January 15, 2026
One of my close friends believes in reincarnation. My Catholic education and faith leave me with no reason to believe in multiple lives. Among other things, my friend claims that all mention of reincarnation was removed from the Bible in ...
Read More →
In Vitro Fertilization: Where Does the Catholic Church Stand?
Pat McCloskey, OFM
January 6, 2026
Is the Catholic Church against in vitro fertilization? If so, why? Isn’t this a compassionate response for couples who want to have children, but either or both spouses have medical conditions that make this unlikely?
Read More →
Suffering from Natural Disasters
Pat McCloskey, OFM
November 30, 2025
Why do you think God inflicts such natural disasters on many innocent, God-loving people?
Read More →






